# Top Real Estate Agents in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN | Cribber

Based on Cribber’s trailing-12-month listing-activity data, Melissa Mendoza ranks first in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN with 2 credited listings.

The 2026-11 edition covers 2025-11-17 through 2026-11-17 in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN, with 31 eligible agents and teams and 33 unique eligible homes. The comparison includes qualifying current and past listing activity, with supporting records linked to the edition.

Selected metric: homes_listed.

Reporting month: 2026-11-01. Cutoff: 2026-11-17T15:34:00.029297+00:00. Published: 2026-11-18T03:18:25.311101+00:00.

Window: 2025-11-17 to 2026-11-17. 31 eligible agents; 33 unique homes.

| Rank | Agent or team | Brokerage | Homes listed | Asking volume | Typical asking price | Priced homes | Listing share | Evidence |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Melissa Mendoza | CENTURY 21 Scheetz | 2 | 754000 | 377000 | 2 | 6.06% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=2c3c7968-fdff-401e-8f33-43ba4e41ac25&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Carlos Higareda | Exp Realty, Llc | 1 | 499900 | 499900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=41fba3e8-a95d-4a9a-a85f-9dfb79262b10&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Harjot Suri | Midland Realty Group, Inc. | 1 | 445000 | 445000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=efcb2d72-9e74-4dac-982d-bfd166ecf879&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Suzanne Mayfield | CENTURY 21 Scheetz | 1 | 434000 | 434000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=8bfe3368-1f2b-4d84-8c41-cd86b60714c8&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Landon Buesching | 1 Percent Lists - Hoosier State Realty LLC | 1 | 400000 | 400000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=3c583746-0b8e-48bc-85b6-f75b128cef3c&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Rusty Harsin | Hoosier, Realtors&#Xae; | 1 | 399900 | 399900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=a1f3c953-5fc9-41fd-9059-01235e865647&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Shamika Myers | F.C. Tucker Company - Fishers/Geist | 1 | 399900 | 399900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=a6c287cc-52bc-4d34-89ab-7d2544d4e54e&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Mukul Khanna | Re/Max Advanced Realty | 1 | 389900 | 389900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=031cbd82-d361-4ea9-8b51-bd2e4ef42795&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Jeannie Grant | Highgarden Real Estate | 1 | 369900 | 369900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=2ed54797-45ae-4282-a5b7-b72755d2902d&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Alisa Lee | Alisa Lee Realty | 1 | 365000 | 365000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=793c0947-989a-4b47-b985-1ceaa19bc3bc&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Rene Reynoso | eXp Realty, LLC | 1 | 360000 | 360000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=c791b82f-03da-48f7-afa5-bf0f74aa9cb6&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Keith Albrecht | RE/MAX Real Estate Groups | 1 | 359000 | 359000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=0e0468e7-04ac-4ec3-bc9c-9882b6740e36&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Natalie Evans | Match House Realty Group LLC | 1 | 340900 | 340900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=3e11d53a-d29a-4eed-814c-16874bbf20e2&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Kelly Smotherman | White Stag Realty, LLC | 1 | 335000 | 335000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=629d673b-2aba-4484-9eb0-346d2335154f&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Eric Mender | Trueblood Real Estate | 1 | 315000 | 315000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=7380f93a-a0d9-4570-be72-f61e238d4434&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | James Talhelm | Hoosier, Realtors&#Xae; | 1 | 299000 | 299000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=49da9ac1-643a-4ada-ad33-9388485b5582&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Susy Bishop | Carpenter Realtors, Brownsburg | 1 | 294500 | 294500 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=80bc492c-566b-4157-a8db-d26b2fd9bd60&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Andrew Neal Group | eXp Realty, LLC | 1 | 289900 | 289900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=c31f43ef-e76e-4d86-8cc0-a65af0df629b&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Christina Rice | REALTY WORLD-Harbert Company | 1 | 285000 | 285000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=237180bd-fa71-4710-ac03-de6840255a69&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Denis Obrien | Keller Williams Indy Metro S | 1 | 280000 | 280000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=58b58e47-61a7-4923-b3ee-0bce1d18a9cb&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Bradley Mccleerey | Mark Dietel Realty, LLC | 1 | 269900 | 269900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=9b1eb754-cf21-4d71-817d-bfab74ec52ee&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Karl Vierling | Carpenter Realtors, Greenwood | 1 | 269900 | 269900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=bdc701ab-80b7-4409-a9c9-a0e7199b94ae&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Allyson Brooks | Mark Dietel Realty, LLC | 1 | 260000 | 260000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=1e131801-2ca1-4036-b3ce-4d05098f712d&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Julie Preston-hofmeister | F.C. Tucker Company - East | 1 | 260000 | 260000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=4d7d4699-81e0-4faa-b49f-d6fa3a52b979&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Carla D. Higgins | Keller Williams Indy Metro S | 1 | 249999 | 249999 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=4f5d9e26-dfba-49e4-8ed1-c7be2e91de22&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Daniel Moran | Jeff Paxson Real Estate Browns | 1 | 230000 | 230000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=a0a37a4d-aa5c-4a55-b872-0d171688d7fc&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Eric Forney | Keller Williams Indy Metro W | 1 | 224900 | 224900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=269c1b86-7dd5-47b4-aaf9-0c12aeaec0dc&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Patrick Keller | Crestpoint Real Estate | 1 | 185000 | 185000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=76455c37-ba74-4649-ad73-e7d9b6751dfb&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | David Orman | Tomorrow Realty, Inc. | 1 | 170000 | 170000 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=f406da8e-8ed4-40e0-a8f9-ebc848146519&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Tony Papalia | New Quantum Realty Group | 1 | 159900 | 159900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=d4daefc9-6a2e-47ec-bf4b-f8fa78bc76ec&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Seth Dawson | Connected America Real Estate LLC | 1 | 99900 | 99900 | 1 | 3.03% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents/evidence?agent=06b9aa40-e6ce-482f-8385-439248b88b41&month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed) |

## Frequently asked questions

### Who are the best real estate agents in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN?

Cribber doesn’t rate agent quality or use reviews. The published Homes Listed ranking for Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN shows Melissa Mendoza (2 homes listed), Carlos Higareda (1 homes listed), and Harjot Suri (1 homes listed) among the most active listing agents over the last 12 months. Activity shows local experience. It doesn’t guarantee the best fit for you.

### How do I choose the best realtor in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN?

Shortlist agents with recent listings in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN at your price point using the table. Read independent reviews and interview two or three before signing. [Check a license with your state licensing board](https://www.arello.org/index.cfm/resources/regulatory-agencies)

### Who is the top real estate agent in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN?

Based on Cribber’s trailing-12-month listing-activity data, Melissa Mendoza ranks first in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN with 2 credited listings.

### Who has the highest asking volume in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN?

Based on Cribber’s trailing-12-month listing-activity data, Melissa Mendoza ranks first in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN with $754,000 in asking volume.

### How does Cribber rank agents?

Homes Listed counts distinct qualifying homes credited to each agent or team. Asking Volume adds their selected observed asking prices and requires a usable price for every qualifying home. Equal values share a competition rank; paid placement does not change standings. [Read the ranking methodology](https://cribber.ai/agents/methodology)

### How current is this leaderboard?

Rankings are published monthly. This November 2026 edition uses data through Nov 17, 2026, covering Nov 17, 2025 through Nov 17, 2026.

## Methodology

Ranked by distinct homes credited over the trailing 12 months, including both endpoint UTC dates. Qualifying current and past sale listings contribute when their selected listing episode overlaps the reporting window. Recorded sales identify sold homes within that listing record; other off-market homes remain inactive.

A canonical, unit-aware property identity keeps repeat observations of the same home from becoming extra credits. The agents-listings-v7 reader selects the latest qualifying episode before geographic filters. Explicit distinct co-listing agents each receive full credit. Named teams can receive documented credit; team or brokerage membership alone does not create it. Ambiguous attribution is withheld.

Municipalities use official Census boundaries and coordinate assignments. Neighborhoods use retained high-confidence polygon assignments. A home may appear in its city and neighborhood comparisons, once within each geography.

The authoritative reader orders Homes Listed by credited homes, with asking volume and stable agent identity resolving display order. Equal listing counts share a competition rank, including across pages. Observed listing share is credited homes divided by unique eligible homes in the edition; co-listing credits can overlap.

Asking Volume adds the latest usable observed asking price associated with each selected episode. A volume rank requires 100% usable price coverage. These are asking prices rather than recorded sale proceeds. Homes with missing prices still count toward Homes Listed. Typical Asking Price describes the stored median and priced-home sample; historical price-based standings retain their original five-home and 90% coverage eligibility policy.

Each geography freezes the first successful verified capture for its UTC monthly edition. Read the actual reporting window, cutoff and publication date on the page. Daily ingestion prepares evidence separately. Published historical figures are preserved; a correction creates a new revision.

Each comparison covers the geography, reporting window and qualifying records stated in the edition. Supporting listings show the evidence behind the figures. Payment never changes eligibility, counts or rank.

## Cite this leaderboard

Cribber. Top Real Estate Agents in Wanamaker, Indianapolis, IN | Cribber. 2026-11 edition, Homes Listed. Reporting window: 2025-11-17–2026-11-17. Published 2026-11-18T03:18:25.311101+00:00. https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents?month=2026-11&sort=homes_listed

Canonical leaderboard: https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/indianapolis-in/wanamaker/top-agents
