Neighborhoods in Madison

Choose a neighborhood to drill down. Most active first.

Nov 2026 edition · Data through Nov 20, 2026 · Edition details

Top Real Estate Agents in Sherman, Madison, WI

Based on Cribber’s trailing-12-month listing-activity data, Tamara Mcdougal, Seth Pfaehler, Jaclyn Smith, April Johnson share first place in Sherman, Madison, WI with 2 credited listings each.

Agent leaderboard

33 agents · Sorted by homes listed

Agents in Sherman
RankAgent / teamListing share
T-5Aaron WeberCompass Real Estate WisconsinMedian ask $324,9001$325K
T-5Mary Kay RoseneckBerkshire Hathaway HomeServices True RealtyMedian ask $323,5001$324K
T-5The Lavik Home TeamExp Realty, LLCMedian ask $320,0001$320K
T-5John SchneiderExit Realty HGMMedian ask $299,9001$300K
T-5Sandy JoudreyNextHome MidwestMedian ask $299,9001$300K
T-5Kate SomersReal Broker LLCMedian ask $299,0001$299K
T-5Dan SchimelfenygeXp Realty, LLC- WiMedian ask $275,0001$275K
T-5Erika HaarCcl ManagementMedian ask $274,9001$275K
T-5Ken BrennerStark Company RealtorsMedian ask $269,9001$270K
T-5Chris ZieglerRedfin CorporationMedian ask $259,9001$260K
T-5Katie KolakowskiStark Company RealtorsMedian ask $230,0001$230K
T-5Aimee OjedaReal Broker LLCMedian ask $225,0001$225K
T-5Greg StroupeReal Broker LLCMedian ask $159,9001$160K

Showing 21–33 of 33 agents

Understanding these numbers ↓

Ranks are calculated across all 33 agents. Tied agents share a rank, including across pages.

Looking for the best real estate agent in Sherman? Compare 33 local listing agents and realtors in Sherman, Madison, Wisconsin by homes listed and asking volume. Rankings are based on listing data, not paid placement or reviews.

Homes listed leaders: 1. Tamara Mcdougal · 1. Seth Pfaehler · 1. Jaclyn Smith · 1. April Johnson

Asking volume leaders: 1. Tamara Mcdougal · 2. Seth Pfaehler · 3. Jaclyn Smith

How rankings work

Agents ranked

33

November 2026 published edition

Unique homes listed

38

Nov 20, 2025 – Nov 20, 2026

Data through

Nov 20, 2026

Published cutoff

Most homes listed

2

4 agents tied · this edition

November 2026 edition · 33 agents · data through Nov 20, 2026.

Frequently asked questions

Who are the best real estate agents in Sherman, Madison, WI?

Cribber doesn’t rate agent quality or use reviews. The published Homes Listed ranking for Sherman, Madison, WI shows Tamara Mcdougal (2 homes listed), Seth Pfaehler (2 homes listed), and Jaclyn Smith (2 homes listed) among the most active listing agents over the last 12 months. Activity shows local experience. It doesn’t guarantee the best fit for you.

How do I choose the best realtor in Sherman, Madison, WI?

Shortlist agents with recent listings in Sherman, Madison, WI at your price point using the table. Read independent reviews and interview two or three before signing. Check a license with your state licensing board.

Who is the top real estate agent in Sherman, Madison, WI?

Based on Cribber’s trailing-12-month listing-activity data, Tamara Mcdougal, Seth Pfaehler, Jaclyn Smith, April Johnson share first place in Sherman, Madison, WI with 2 credited listings each.

Who has the highest asking volume in Sherman, Madison, WI?

Based on Cribber’s trailing-12-month listing-activity data, Tamara Mcdougal ranks first in Sherman, Madison, WI with $815,000 in asking volume.

How does Cribber rank agents?

Homes Listed counts distinct qualifying homes credited to each agent or team. Asking Volume adds their selected observed asking prices and requires a usable price for every qualifying home. Equal values share a competition rank; paid placement does not change standings. Read the ranking methodology.

How current is this leaderboard?

Rankings are published monthly. This November 2026 edition uses data through Nov 20, 2026, covering Nov 20, 2025 through Nov 20, 2026.

Reading the rankings

Listings
Distinct qualifying homes credited to an agent or team during the reporting window. Current and past listings contribute under the same rules; co-listing agents each receive credit.
Asking volume
The combined selected observed asking prices of credited homes. A volume rank requires a usable asking price for every qualifying home.
Observed listing share
Credited homes ÷ 38 unique homes in this leaderboard. Co-listing credits overlap, so shares can total more than 100%. The denominator is this edition’s qualifying homes.

About the data

November 2026 edition

Reporting window
–
Coverage
33 agents & teams · 38 unique homes
Published
Data cutoff

Updated monthly.

Sources & reuse

Cite this leaderboard

Cribber. Top Real Estate Agents in Sherman, Madison, WI. November 2026 edition. Listings and asking volume, Nov 20, 2025–Nov 20, 2026. Published Nov 20, 2026.

Leaderboard downloads

The same dated edition, ready to read or analyze.

Markdown is readable text. JSON includes ranking data, dates, definitions, and evidence links.

Leaderboard editions

Explore the published monthly record.