# Top Real Estate Agents in Sanibel, FL | Cribber

Based on Cribber’s trailing-12-month listing-activity data, Eric  Pfeifer ranks first in Sanibel, FL with 67 credited listings.

The 2026-10 edition covers 2025-10-26 through 2026-10-26 in Sanibel, FL, with 207 eligible agents and teams and 899 unique eligible homes. The comparison includes qualifying current and past listing activity, with supporting records linked to the edition.

Selected metric: homes_listed.

Reporting month: 2026-10-01. Cutoff: 2026-10-26T17:08:54.734843+00:00. Published: 2026-10-26T17:08:54.734843+00:00.

Window: 2025-10-26 to 2026-10-26. 207 eligible agents; 899 unique homes.

| Rank | Agent or team | Brokerage | Homes Listed | Asking Volume | Typical Asking Price | Priced homes | Observed listing share | Evidence |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Eric  Pfeifer | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 67 | 94075700 | 1049000 | 67 | 7.45% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d45b8935-1566-4e78-930b-bea2b8a17d1c&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 2 | Phaidra Mcdermott | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 50 | 86776390 | 1364000 | 50 | 5.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b67a5cfc-c692-4865-84b7-220f6a315bcc&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 3 | Jeffrey Burns | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 43 | 72596398 | 1128500 | 43 | 4.78% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a70afb7b-a4d4-47f2-88d9-ae35bf9c6eff&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 4 | Karen Bell & The Bell Team | VIP Realty Group Inc. | 35 | 39861000 | 899000 | 35 | 3.89% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=4a0d283e-7176-4774-a420-4f53ddedb3dc&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 4 | Susan Mccallion | McCallion & McCallion Realty | 35 | 38998700 | 974900 | 35 | 3.89% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=c2db1dd4-9e0b-491f-b856-7432e6cc3591&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 6 | Jennifer Mcsorley | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 32 | 34593000 | 997000 | 32 | 3.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=99d5bca4-01a2-4c2f-82b6-f6858078c55e&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 7 | Kelly Huguenin | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 31 | 21542999 | 599000 | 31 | 3.45% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=1f26e64f-c9a2-42da-94e5-41cb75dbae77&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 8 | Teresa Baker | VIP Realty Group, Inc | 23 | 27935500 | 949000 | 23 | 2.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=612b6103-1713-4b17-aab6-59205175bbff&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 8 | Kerri Maw | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 23 | 27732000 | 795000 | 23 | 2.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=91095d2c-5a07-4757-a3fc-a5870790e922&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 10 | Wendy Kirschner | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 18 | 20798700 | 861350 | 18 | 2.00% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=33418059-74f6-4d25-bda3-2d375f5a8cef&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 11 | Mary Bondurant, Agent | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 16 | 19961000 | 1172500 | 16 | 1.78% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=5caf3734-9bc4-40c0-927d-4bc6d8e0261a&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 12 | Cindy Sitton | Royal Shell Real Estate - Viva | 15 | 18363500 | 1195000 | 15 | 1.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=1fa66b6e-51c7-4df8-a872-5a80ecdfad49&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 13 | Becky Mulka | VIP Realty Group, Inc | 13 | 14594998 | 1050000 | 13 | 1.45% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=fcc71051-6347-42d1-8df0-e9115e616031&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 13 | Christopher Kirchner | Keller Williams Realty Fort My | 13 | 12144000 | 750000 | 13 | 1.45% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=9c171ec3-1c9d-410e-a92f-f941ff06e24a&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 15 | Mike Mcmurray | Royal Shell Real Estate - Viva | 12 | 62906000 | 3019500 | 12 | 1.33% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e793e34c-40ed-471d-b556-49928ad2a0fa&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 16 | Schuldenfrei, David | Gopher Enterprises of Sanibel & Captiva Islands Corp | 11 | 15395000 | 1090000 | 11 | 1.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=93bf4353-a838-4b64-acb0-0d5f720348e7&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 17 | Dawn Ramsey | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 10 | 20147000 | 1274000 | 10 | 1.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=55780b04-d714-470b-9d2d-139371b1b22a&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 17 | Rose Gibney-dakos | VIP Realty Group, Inc | 10 | 10079535 | 949500 | 10 | 1.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=bd2168b8-68bc-49c0-b8c2-e71b1d377a63&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 19 | Evan Dupont | Michael Saunders & Company | 9 | 11515000 | 1375000 | 9 | 1.00% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=0d4c2456-df04-4a9a-be4d-8a562e5b9d0b&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 19 | Milissa Sprecher | McCallion & McCallion Realty | 9 | 10146000 | 950000 | 9 | 1.00% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=60e60ee9-5bae-44b8-8741-b9fb018d2f3e&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 19 | Mary Ann Cowart | Royal Shell Real Estate - Captiva Island | 9 | 8382999 | 925000 | 9 | 1.00% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=99e53cf9-190c-40ca-a491-06eddb1092c3&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 19 | Bill Lejeune | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 9 | 7511000 | 925000 | 9 | 1.00% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b060a733-b8af-49a6-9b01-5933711c4745&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 23 | Babs Maughan | John R. Wood Properties | 8 | 12577000 | 1397000 | 8 | 0.89% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=41e30b9c-81cc-4e8e-801c-19619857baaa&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 23 | Brooke Brownyard | Kingfisher Real Estate, Inc. | 8 | 9572000 | 972500 | 8 | 0.89% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=61cae089-4cc6-4cd2-9164-fc60edf1c64f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 23 | Andre Arensman | JOHN R. WOOD, ISLAND REAL ESTATE | 8 | 7733000 | 877000 | 8 | 0.89% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d3d7a5c9-0599-46e5-ac68-e9e122899adc&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 23 | Jennifer Berry | Royal Shell Real Estate - Captiva Island | 8 | 7312000 | 862000 | 8 | 0.89% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=fc245f36-8ba7-4f71-a625-7983f5b903a0&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 27 | Barbara Maughan | JOHN R. WOOD, ISLAND REAL ESTATE | 7 | 15304000 | 1999000 | 7 | 0.78% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e7ff2ce0-8596-4fdc-a277-4917783a6edb&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 27 | Deb Stone | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 7 | 10460000 | 1330000 | 7 | 0.78% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=2077515c-e774-44de-aa30-b61539f13a0a&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 27 | Brendan Albright | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 7 | 7311000 | 995000 | 7 | 0.78% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=f8d5e595-28f0-4cfc-813f-8170056a299d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 27 | Bryan Hall | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 7 | 6632000 | 850000 | 7 | 0.78% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e900f730-be2b-4bd9-a955-2db63b53b149&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 27 | Robert Pailes | SBL Realty Group, LLC | 7 | 4696000 | 639000 | 7 | 0.78% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=95cb5381-89f0-49c3-afbb-a0c19ddba770&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 32 | Ken King | SanCap Gateway Realty | 6 | 10088999 | 1485000 | 6 | 0.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=269e4e26-61db-40d7-b28f-e2a3c50e98bc&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 32 | Tim Drobnyk | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 6 | 8795000 | 999500 | 6 | 0.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=8f14aa9c-896d-44cb-ba0d-5ec000b60cdf&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 32 | Steven Fisher | RE/MAX REALTY GROUP | 6 | 7638000 | 892500 | 6 | 0.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=8109920c-ea67-41ce-9f50-397fad602804&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 32 | Gregory Demaras | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 6 | 7479000 | 1099000 | 6 | 0.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=517d46e5-fd38-450a-9cdc-10c52b90659f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 32 | Tina Dicharia | Royal Shell Real Estate - Captiva Island | 6 | 7286000 | 709000 | 6 | 0.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=3161a729-2175-48c4-8867-a1ae7f7e1635&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 32 | Sean Radigan | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 6 | 5881000 | 1072500 | 6 | 0.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=4e447d86-a9ed-4c5b-b41b-1aa8d8973dbd&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 32 | Janka Varmuza | VIP REALTY GROUP | 6 | 5463000 | 570000 | 6 | 0.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e11fa7dd-30f4-445b-9a3f-e70e559cadad&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 32 | Ann Gee | John Gee & Company, Inc. | 6 | 5344800 | 899950 | 6 | 0.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=de3192a9-f743-4d8f-bd41-03f77cc8c96f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 32 | Susan Andrews | SanibelSusan Realty Associates | 6 | 4345999 | 699000 | 6 | 0.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=07176514-8fab-4274-a9a3-b08f76ed8e61&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 32 | Kate Stone Pujol | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 6 | 3988000 | 587500 | 6 | 0.67% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=fa025b1c-c993-4ea0-bf80-5d812ac1140f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 42 | Carolyn Tongyai | JOHN R. WOOD, ISLAND REAL ESTATE | 5 | 8919000 | 1395000 | 5 | 0.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=33bd8da8-d713-4cd4-ba53-544c1d672243&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 42 | Trevor Nette | Royal Shell Real Estate - Captiva Island | 5 | 7639000 | 1095000 | 5 | 0.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=2dcb039c-f36a-4eaa-ac67-5d7cf2d0fdc1&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 42 | Kara Cuscaden | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 5 | 6946000 | 1774000 | 5 | 0.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b8d85e23-ee9a-4614-a80f-ecb1ecb7dcd7&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 42 | Cathie Lewis | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 5 | 4940664 | 825000 | 5 | 0.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=ff276a50-5fe8-4b0e-90f5-d90eb8968770&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 42 | Julie Oberlin | John R. Wood Properties | 5 | 4598900 | 800000 | 5 | 0.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e9279ad1-6fe3-4346-8d9b-8fb56198978b&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 42 | Rachel Walsh | Keller Williams Realty Fort My | 5 | 3768000 | 725000 | 5 | 0.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=80b594db-3e07-4123-b7ec-fc266e276c5b&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 42 | Deb Smith | Michael Saunders & Company | 5 | 3438000 | 599000 | 5 | 0.56% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=dad9457e-c5ec-43fa-9e8a-ebc52467161c&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Gregory Demaras | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 4 | 12558000 | 2347000 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=3a3f1d82-fadb-4184-8e09-1575b038459a&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Valerie Tutor, Agent | KINGFISHER REAL ESTATE INC. | 4 | 9464000 | 2195000 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=8e0936b4-bd98-4425-a033-fcfa93b7b6f2&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Shane Spring | Keyes - Fort Myers | 4 | 7446000 | 1649000 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=ff62bb92-64be-42ec-8c0a-a33234ecbfae&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Jon Archer | Real Broker, LLC | 4 | 6015000 | 885000 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=597534af-73f9-429a-93f1-07c46f4f3cd8&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Louise Hammarberg | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 4 | 3792000 | 882000 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=864258aa-c670-457e-a563-50d2cb8cdec6&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Robyn Moran, Agent | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 4 | 3253000 | 714500 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=512b1a45-e4da-4f4f-9775-7f57a78dcb4a&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Sarah Ashton | Keller Williams Realty Fort My | 4 | 3230000 | 852500 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=955bb76e-391c-4662-ab1b-05804147c5c3&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Tracy A. Walters | Royal Shell Real Estate | 4 | 2925000 | 764000 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e11579b3-3e62-47b5-a37c-758502f1b986&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Jason Lomano | Royal Shell Real Estate - Viva | 4 | 2662000 | 669000 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d744303e-8541-40e0-b506-2f9d1b9e6e8d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Anna Turner | Royal Shell Real Estate - Viva | 4 | 2476000 | 624000 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=0af24637-4fa3-421e-90f7-99e40dce0414&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 49 | Steven K. | beycome.com | 4 | 867900 | 189450 | 4 | 0.44% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=8af4145b-5635-4a10-89a9-f66ffc583a61&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 60 | Cecilia Jane Liichow | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 3 | 7073000 | 1385000 | 3 | 0.33% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d643f31e-69fc-4b8b-85ad-bbc96a5436ae&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 60 | Catherine Rosario | Royal Shell Real Estate - Viva | 3 | 5914900 | 795900 | 3 | 0.33% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=03884916-06b0-4748-91a7-701174c48710&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 60 | Barry Waddell | John R. Wood Properties | 3 | 5244000 | 1950000 | 3 | 0.33% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=330771a5-4b6e-4f4b-b9bf-aa98c399f458&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 60 | Marty Stokes | Timbers FL Real Estate Company LLC | 3 | 4487000 | 1549000 | 3 | 0.33% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=9ba10849-db4e-4137-a48a-e9a085e6afdc&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 60 | Michael J. Newell | MJ Newell Realty LLC | 3 | 4460000 | 1250000 | 3 | 0.33% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=7bdcf655-761c-43e3-8312-836c0f55e0f0&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 60 | Chip Wolfe | RE MAX Realty Group | 3 | 4048000 | 839000 | 3 | 0.33% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=63ed0d8f-055d-433f-b967-18f98a5451e5&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 60 | Susan Dunn | VIP Realty Group, Inc | 3 | 3428000 | 1050000 | 3 | 0.33% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=f764d125-7062-4ab8-bf07-13b04fc9a91d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 60 | Brian Murty | Royal Shell Real Estate - Viva | 3 | 2514000 | 895000 | 3 | 0.33% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=60de83e0-1d3d-4ae0-b544-c48621542f0f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 60 | Charles Bergstrom | RE/MAX REALTY GROUP | 3 | 2388900 | 874900 | 3 | 0.33% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=db595794-3c2e-430f-864e-b22853b24f73&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Ermina Matic | Matic Properties LLC | 2 | 7500000 | 3750000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=bb5365ca-c5e0-437b-b199-b88fa66b56f3&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Virginia H Lesko | Century 21 AllPoints Realty (DBA) | 2 | 6237500 | 3118750 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d47da8ed-4ebb-4c8d-948a-67fa540b6983&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Brooks Selby | JOHN R. WOOD, ISLAND REAL ESTATE | 2 | 5295000 | 2647500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a52d0052-f16c-4ed0-b5ec-3649bfea4944&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | David Saunders | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 2 | 3690000 | 1845000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=5e7cd6c3-7231-4c65-a706-376bb0055cf1&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Daniel Wexler | VIP Realty Group, Inc | 2 | 3364000 | 1682000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=1ed79492-da54-46f5-98d5-7cd48474a2a1&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Candis Daugherty | Local Real Estate LLC | 2 | 3300000 | 1650000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d2b680e8-844c-4bb6-8e9d-935dfd60bc56&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Felipe Miranda | Royal Shell Real Estate - 5th Avenue | 2 | 3148000 | 1574000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=cff49464-8df3-468b-8aac-275655e5f9d9&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Kristine Cardinale Pa | JOHN R. WOOD, ISLAND REAL ESTATE | 2 | 3030000 | 1515000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e0d616bd-bc21-4e5b-98ba-950cd7c91a8e&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Stephanie Hoeh | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 2 | 2715000 | 1357500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=8968e34e-41ca-4aa6-88b5-11b4756cf67b&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Kelly Sackman | Royal Shell Real Estate - Fort Myers | 2 | 2578000 | 1289000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=01d4842c-24cd-451e-bb62-2c87cbc71a97&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Bob Radigan | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 2 | 2529000 | 1264500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=dbbcaafa-061a-4c89-b847-ef4d00525e95&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Wendy Humphrey | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 2 | 2489000 | 1244500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=8d3beed3-9523-45cf-a978-c210c28a7032&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Liz Podolsky | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 2 | 2469900 | 1234950 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=688f5ce2-28df-40bc-962e-3edfabae377f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Geoffrey Selby | John R. Wood Properties | 2 | 2400000 | 1200000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=3c7a6454-cd64-40bf-9e20-85037b19f680&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Cathy Gerasin | Royal Shell Real Estate - Viva | 2 | 2399900 | 1199950 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=3b4abb8e-4381-479e-8113-bc99681a0224&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Eric Lord | Vip Realty Group Inc | 2 | 2325000 | 1162500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=74c7d68f-88e9-4ad1-b9eb-e7474d75aa80&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Amy Zajic | Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Florida Realty | 2 | 2320000 | 1160000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=96956f78-fbfc-48c3-ace1-13c6ae4b9ce2&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Deborah M Gleason | VIP REALTY GROUP | 2 | 2018000 | 1009000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=bea537a3-72fa-4a5b-8fd5-57615742f58a&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Melanie Holaway | JOHN R. WOOD, ISLAND REAL ESTATE | 2 | 1979000 | 989500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=64064464-2eb1-4777-9e21-208e644c46cd&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Jayne Lumley | Michael Saunders & Company | 2 | 1978000 | 989000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=fc2efd01-9c56-4f79-b61c-56935093af1f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Lori Schulz | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 2 | 1945000 | 972500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=6d2bf44f-22e2-4b0b-a15b-f35b87cce2e4&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Mary Abshire Sres | John R. Wood Properties | 2 | 1944000 | 972000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a2d57fc6-abfa-4ad4-aba8-f7d1459ff5f8&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Allison Duenas | Remax Alliance Group | 2 | 1935000 | 967500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=bd99a1f4-2733-47e5-a482-0ed1722130e2&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Hannah Tucker | Hovland Realty, LLC | 2 | 1900000 | 950000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=7965831b-fc4c-48d6-8c8b-1c3d639dea91&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Steve Bacardi | Coldwell Banker Realty | 2 | 1850000 | 925000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=f8037ef7-ce5b-48f2-b860-b47e72cd84e8&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Dolibet Estevez | United Realty Group Inc | 2 | 1667000 | 833500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=5a2f91d6-57b3-43e0-ad44-4f70d5cc08ae&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Arika Bjorkedal | Michael Saunders & Company | 2 | 1625000 | 812500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=318667c0-a631-4e95-bfbd-97e0b76401d5&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Tony Dibiase | John R. Wood Properties | 2 | 1622000 | 811000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e5359221-71c6-4767-89d1-64cb32d95635&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Ann Gee | John Gee & Company, Inc. | 2 | 1439900 | 719950 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=0a7b52e5-fdc5-48a7-8900-f4c1a887d7ba&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Robert Hagmann | West Islands Realty Inc | 2 | 1198000 | 599000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=93f9deb3-da2a-499a-90ab-46dd094ec1ab&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Joyce Lathrop | Kerri Theisen Realty, Inc | 2 | 965000 | 482500 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b8896e2c-04d9-4bcd-9cf3-dbe83678deef&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Nelica Krekic | Nexthome South Pointe | 2 | 820000 | 410000 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=430f97c4-7a11-4287-81e8-c9040159eca3&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 69 | Beycome | BEYCOME OF FLORIDA LLC | 2 | 337500 | 168750 | 2 | 0.22% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=12b25718-0e1c-4a8e-9bb0-8397c8cf0d41&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Tiffany Mcquaid, Broker/owner | McQuaid & Company LLC | 1 | 33880000 | 33880000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a9523333-68f8-4d31-ad8a-8705cd716724&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Mike And Andrew Darda | COMPASS | 1 | 24950000 | 24950000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a8dd8e59-8b99-4609-9c32-f6983bc6a8b2&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Joseph Ghannam | Premiere Plus Realty Co. | 1 | 8150000 | 8150000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=6d9df002-837c-4594-9dd2-4c340d57cdd2&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Michael Billheimer | Kingfisher Real Estate, Inc. | 1 | 4500000 | 4500000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=22f48c06-893e-4aa9-87fa-a1ca509d912c&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Courtney Lawton | Sellstate Priority Realty | 1 | 3900000 | 3900000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=9c8b5649-94ec-46f7-8bf3-6c8eaa2ddd8d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Amanda Potter | Pinnacle Realty Advisors | 1 | 3900000 | 3900000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=c0f25530-919d-4984-a4d9-6e417af2192a&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | James Bates | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 1 | 3795000 | 3795000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=aa74c7da-66c6-4e07-85db-a94f01663bae&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Onias Derilus | Pure Equity Realty Llc | 1 | 3495000 | 3495000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b7a5f756-8166-4b83-8d1f-09ce2fdd0249&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Tanner Miller | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 1 | 3195000 | 3195000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=8675096b-215f-41bc-b8a7-35978d04c181&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Tiffany Burns | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 1 | 2999000 | 2999000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a5ccab52-e35b-4b3e-8e23-f0bd1149248e&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Joel Goodman | Royal Shell Real Estate - Viva | 1 | 2950000 | 2950000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e3e8696a-0c71-4acb-8b1f-3ee1b6cd8878&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Betsy Kimrey | VIP REALTY GROUP | 1 | 2750000 | 2750000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=33dc1f2a-da00-4669-8759-1aacbd98041a&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Jayne Lumley | Michael Saunders & Company | 1 | 2695000 | 2695000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=c14bb9b1-43a3-42ff-84c2-4d955c18ff17&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | David Gruninger | William Raveis Real Estate - Naples - 720 5th Ave South | 1 | 2500000 | 2500000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=6a83963b-aa84-42fd-8265-da8106f8a064&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Andrew Adler | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 1 | 2495000 | 2495000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b2382c86-b31d-44af-9cc4-abc65c862e2c&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Kathryn Gaeta | Michael Saunders & Company | 1 | 2197000 | 2197000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=3dc9d972-156d-4799-ac56-efa95a416936&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Catherine Brunsell | Vip Realty Group Inc | 1 | 2149000 | 2149000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b8fd66d9-d371-4d4a-b07d-b03f5f3956c0&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Debbie Staley | VIP Realty Group, Inc | 1 | 1595000 | 1595000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=c2f054e5-53d5-403e-8dc4-ce31b88f010e&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Yeisly Ochoa | Premiere Plus Realty Co. | 1 | 1550000 | 1550000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=fc5a3b29-e2ee-4c9d-807e-93527fd74088&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Maureen Ahmed | John R. Wood Properties | 1 | 1500000 | 1500000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=0ac3d43e-4ae9-472e-97e5-af229e80de53&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Jonathan Richards | Realty Rents And Sales, Llc | 1 | 1500000 | 1500000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b74c2495-d824-4937-b7dc-7eb6fdc5006e&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Kyle Sweeney | Catching Coastal Realty | 1 | 1499000 | 1499000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=fe31822f-d572-4f09-9385-40839f34b402&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Connie Walters | Michael Saunders & Company | 1 | 1495000 | 1495000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=ef15e1a6-0e74-4c5d-b63e-3125b700fb2b&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Char Seuffert | Remax Sunshine | 1 | 1489000 | 1489000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b8d42cbf-1ee6-453e-9705-23a549be66e3&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | April Nixon | RE MAX Trend | 1 | 1475000 | 1475000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=21c0c8d8-df7b-4404-bda3-b7805d3bf288&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Brian Johnson | Michael Saunders & Company | 1 | 1450000 | 1450000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=827fec0b-7ae6-481e-be09-269178d3e493&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Rafael Dagnesses | EXP REALTY LLC | 1 | 1399900 | 1399900 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=38909f2a-adea-4462-bd32-13aae8549bf2&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Susan Christiano | ELITE EDGE FL REALTY | 1 | 1399000 | 1399000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e7b5454a-6bc8-40b6-a42b-bae48d4f0ca9&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Elizabeth Podolsky | Kingfisher Real Estate, Inc. | 1 | 1395000 | 1395000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a64b1f55-2146-4a9d-aeee-63e9e74bf4f7&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Petra Svobodova | PS Florida Realty LLC | 1 | 1395000 | 1395000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=f84c7c4f-e072-411a-be63-1abaebe14744&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Stephanie Ostlie | Catching Coastal Realty | 1 | 1349000 | 1349000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b0acd8a4-0b3f-4242-a4b7-49e94b85bde7&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Stephen Obrien | Steves Property Group Llc | 1 | 1290000 | 1290000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=c1725417-919a-419a-8bb5-4954d6d12080&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Judith Anglin | LPT Realty LLC | 1 | 1280000 | 1280000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=adcf0b64-bd00-4ddb-ae18-8486a18726ee&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Beth Barton | Coastal Brokerage Llc | 1 | 1225000 | 1225000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=02a3c850-628f-4af3-8f84-190cd83827d1&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Carolina Depombo | Premier Sotheby's International Realty | 1 | 1195000 | 1195000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=1d3eed94-9815-4335-9bef-4ef5ed69e18e&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Kelsey Smith | Kingfisher Real Estate, Inc. | 1 | 1175000 | 1175000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=3617f259-bdaf-42d2-b600-eba9c310501f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Lisa Newmeyer-cochrane | RE/MAX REALTY GROUP | 1 | 1150000 | 1150000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=1833a191-0f9e-4a6d-860b-721ee9ad5e34&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Damon Vetere | Coldwell Banker Realty | 1 | 1149000 | 1149000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=19cca123-bcfb-4df6-8d5d-060e0ec805c4&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | James Senkeleski | JOHN R. WOOD, ISLAND REAL ESTATE | 1 | 1099000 | 1099000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=fc7f05f5-a834-4b74-b0e2-6a4cfd45c05c&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Rj Hernandez, Gri, Clhms | Phantom Real Estate | 1 | 1085000 | 1085000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=31d0f864-0017-4a90-97f6-223b05f0f591&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Stephanie Harne | Berkshire Hathaway HomeServices Florida Realty | 1 | 1000000 | 1000000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=52a7dc51-d7a6-49d7-993a-166d218a77ed&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Stokes, Joan | Timbers FL Real Estate Company LLC | 1 | 995000 | 995000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e79c68f8-044d-4aeb-a5a8-ea97dce2f42f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Joan A. Crompton | William Raveis Real Estate | 1 | 990000 | 990000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=db9d656a-6f7f-45a9-8ca9-ffbe7e33b46d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Amy Wainwright | VIP REALTY GROUP | 1 | 984000 | 984000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=49c5e152-4821-4379-9cd1-bccac063c6cf&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Mike Billheimer | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 1 | 959000 | 959000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=7b6ef760-d6e1-4635-a052-a81c75619210&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Mary Dowling | The Agency Naples | 1 | 950000 | 950000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=090efc26-5fc9-40e7-9979-f68c8259ddfb&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Fred Newman | Royal Shell Real Estate - Captiva Island | 1 | 949900 | 949900 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a248ec05-ee1c-4f1b-a42c-5b892ae6942b&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Jessica Nolan | Keller Williams Realty Ft Myer | 1 | 949000 | 949000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=08d86adb-d36f-43bf-a83f-da026d771add&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Skye Leber | Epique Realty, INC | 1 | 939000 | 939000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=340b3c98-bc48-40f6-ab4c-50722b44312d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Janell Clark | RE MAX Trend | 1 | 925000 | 925000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d5337d4f-4605-461a-8366-ff32c1f54609&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Jim Wible, Agent | FUTURE HOME REALTY INC | 1 | 924800 | 924800 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a594d781-f453-4791-b403-ebb996042a5e&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Jeff Gerrero | Realty World J. Pavich R.E. | 1 | 900777 | 900777 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=c74c95b6-298c-4341-8cd3-752d063631d2&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Michal Showalter | Home Team Advantage Realty | 1 | 899000 | 899000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=1c28420a-751c-40c8-a539-d5cb7047f921&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Chloe Bowman | COMPASS | 1 | 899000 | 899000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=5ff385f7-c52a-4f82-acf9-17c24d607996&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Jenny Moorhead | Cornerstone Coastal Properties | 1 | 899000 | 899000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=60b49bdc-c789-4f83-bb0f-a8c1924d73e6&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | David Anderson | SanibelSusan Realty Associates | 1 | 899000 | 899000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=ce9dddff-fb72-4db7-9d87-c6e8a1109dc6&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Scott R Morrison | Premier Tropical Realty, Llc | 1 | 897000 | 897000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a8b85399-b95b-4df3-b1d5-9e4aac446151&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Heather Caine | Keller Wiliams, LLC | 1 | 889000 | 889000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=5b96d8cc-6465-486d-845e-42a2f47eece4&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Christopher Reetz, Pa | The Agency Naples | 1 | 875000 | 875000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d6b71a20-1125-490b-b8b9-272afd8064be&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Kimberly Powers | John R. Wood Properties | 1 | 850000 | 850000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=68c72807-2981-4595-987a-e4d7d3be84ee&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Charlie Sobczak | VIP REALTY GROUP | 1 | 847555 | 847555 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=5d8581d7-e3e6-4581-aa83-5ed5378d2fce&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Melyssa Gonzalez | Avanti Way | 1 | 830660 | 830660 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=5e33ba7b-01c6-4917-9169-86ffd0be18fa&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Jorge Mirabal | J. Mirabal Realty, Inc. | 1 | 830000 | 830000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=fa193610-ef0f-4ce2-8a42-599f7f15fb0a&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Mike Billheimer | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 1 | 809000 | 809000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=39b5f507-863d-4852-aebe-4149284d56be&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Dawn Godsil | Durling & Associates, Inc. | 1 | 799000 | 799000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b5651a98-8687-4145-a5e0-26e70c2bca76&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Mary Morris | Michael Saunders & Company | 1 | 799000 | 799000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b75e4ed4-9ae9-43e9-802e-3af8d2d43864&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Deborah Staley | Royal Shell Real Estate - Captiva Island | 1 | 799000 | 799000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d457371f-325f-4cc5-93a8-5f36760230f0&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Megan Chionis | Serhant-Naples | 1 | 795000 | 795000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=0fb5dc61-41f7-4fc6-9f2c-c35eeb960845&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | William Tomlinson | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 1 | 795000 | 795000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=491c0640-f0ca-43fa-897a-eab5d158534d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Justin O'hara | Premiere Plus Realty Co | 1 | 795000 | 795000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=6b287c1d-c409-4f4c-b78c-6b2246835695&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Scott Fader | JOSEPH WALTER REALTY LLC | 1 | 795000 | 795000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=c38781d5-7f3f-4af3-b6a3-a9f139833927&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Loukas M. Masouras | ROG MVP Collier County LLC | 1 | 794990 | 794990 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=3eea65af-d524-4784-920f-bec1ac309985&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Curtis Primeaux | McCallion & McCallion Realty | 1 | 790000 | 790000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e538906b-747a-438a-b052-9e1e67c9e925&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Mark D. Hetrick | List In Mls Realty, Llc | 1 | 789900 | 789900 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=fc8a3d25-3717-4e07-8444-482409fd549b&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Michal Showalter | Home Team Advantage Realty | 1 | 789000 | 789000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=247b8d8c-371a-45b7-8342-4137d6f839db&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Julie Millam | Gulf Coast Living Real Estate, Inc | 1 | 734900 | 734900 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=dfb0699f-6798-4f87-b587-335fa8f6111d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Dana Foster | JOHN R. WOOD, ISLAND REAL ESTATE | 1 | 725000 | 725000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=c98b86d5-527d-447e-8b92-6dd40aa64ed5&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Iris Aloia | Michael Saunders & Company | 1 | 699950 | 699950 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=cf820ec9-3210-4616-a436-46c38fbb978f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Greg Demaras | Pfeifer Realty Group LLC | 1 | 699000 | 699000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=7177b6a5-a299-497b-9a6d-6b37edc1315d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Ralph Nudi | Epique Realty Inc | 1 | 685000 | 685000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=a9048eae-0fed-4e30-a1bc-2688549a6158&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Sarah Sanzica | Palm Paradise Realty Group, LLC | 1 | 685000 | 685000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=bbc761ef-f98f-4bad-939c-6eec95b06d7f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Charlie Sobczak | VIP Realty Group, Inc | 1 | 675555 | 675555 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e8b9cc8e-3223-444b-852e-127be4cf223d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Paul Rose | Vip Realty Group Inc | 1 | 649000 | 649000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=902c7d7b-fdcf-476a-8c2d-e14086b84f32&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Carla Nix | COLDWELL BANKER SUNSTAR REALTY | 1 | 599000 | 599000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=3483c9e6-5908-4e4c-ac44-6c8916a688a2&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Mary Bartos And The Bartos Group | PREMIERE PLUS REALTY CO. | 1 | 590000 | 590000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=27d3b40e-966d-40c8-81df-9b3035891dc6&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | John Bondurant | Kingfisher Real Estate Inc. | 1 | 579000 | 579000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=9bba7b86-938d-4e69-9c5d-08705482e7fb&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Marilyn Worley | SanCap Gateway Realty | 1 | 575000 | 575000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=09735fde-9c56-45fb-93bb-d0fd46d685e9&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Donald Deluca | Royal Shell Real Estate - Fort Myers | 1 | 575000 | 575000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=5c157bf3-b79e-4e64-90a0-6dd957f8f9ec&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Youbel Montesino | LPT REALTY LLC | 1 | 575000 | 575000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=5f6ab157-8154-4e2c-8336-2414250a43ef&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Deluca Donald | Royal Shell Real Estate - Captiva Island | 1 | 575000 | 575000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=74ec8075-7893-4ba2-bcf6-33dadf20f4c2&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Remax Realty Team | RE/MAX Realty Team | 1 | 565000 | 565000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=b047e050-827e-4a70-9be2-6151bcaba830&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Cecilia Sculthorpe | John R Wood Properties - University Dr | 1 | 550000 | 550000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=ab4c2eb7-4250-4f2d-a9ec-7fe981e87345&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Ted Benjamin | Royal Shell Real Estate - Viva | 1 | 549000 | 549000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d3eba870-0314-4126-b041-d20267825fdc&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Alicia Galante | Cornerstone Coastal Properties | 1 | 545000 | 545000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=2947fab1-c51a-4afc-bbf1-f0c1711b004d&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Susanne Perstad | Cape Coral Susan Realty Inc. | 1 | 529000 | 529000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=1eef143c-aac0-4974-b7ce-6564416ecf46&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Leandro Pineiro | LPT Realty LLC | 1 | 515000 | 515000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=fe6a89c1-3c1a-43f8-836c-177dea9bfff4&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Richard Fitch Pa | Premiere Plus Realty Co. | 1 | 510000 | 510000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=6a72f54b-260f-42e1-a09a-95d3c4f4e95b&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Trish Geer | The Keyes Company | 1 | 475000 | 475000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=78bd311f-33e5-4d3b-9a8b-8e618726599c&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Julia Melvin | Kingfisher Real Estate, Inc. | 1 | 450000 | 450000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=69b66a5d-edde-420d-a8bc-74719edc6b53&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Renee Schmidt | Realty One Group MVP | 1 | 447007 | 447007 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=6d68bb90-4700-40e7-9872-89a58f8d79c5&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Re Max Estates | Re/Max Hallmark Realty | 1 | 400000 | 400000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=036bf376-4509-4f1c-8b09-8bee65b8d220&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Kathleen Waite | Keller Williams Realty Fort Myers and the Islands | 1 | 400000 | 400000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=65940347-3c02-4847-aea7-e88c98f5710f&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Terri Shrodi | Royal Shell Real Estate - Fort Myers | 1 | 399999 | 399999 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=d5c970b5-451e-4e1d-9eb9-04d100e2ccf5&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Colby Heuseveldt | Steelbridge Realty LLC | 1 | 319000 | 319000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=241e9bd0-5d45-4bf6-a110-20b2d77a0156&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Carol Robbins 239-287-6905 | Mobile Home Lady | 1 | 198000 | 198000 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=e0617d6f-85db-45ab-bc56-1195c567f1c4&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |
| 102 | Antonette Fazlic | SHE SELLS FLORIDA LLC | 1 | 99500 | 99500 | 1 | 0.11% | [Records](https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents/evidence?agent=31f2d45a-be28-4cb1-92dc-acc996747dbc&month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed) |

## Methodology

Ranked by distinct homes credited over the trailing 12 months, including both endpoint UTC dates. Qualifying current and past sale listings contribute when their selected listing episode overlaps the reporting window. Recorded sales identify sold homes within that listing record; other off-market homes remain inactive.

A canonical, unit-aware property identity keeps repeat observations of the same home from becoming extra credits. The agents-listings-v7 reader selects the latest qualifying episode before geographic filters. Explicit distinct co-listing agents each receive full credit. Named teams can receive documented credit; team or brokerage membership alone does not create it. Ambiguous attribution is withheld.

Municipalities use official Census boundaries and coordinate assignments. Neighborhoods use retained high-confidence polygon assignments. A home may appear in its city and neighborhood comparisons, once within each geography.

The authoritative reader orders Homes Listed by credited homes, with asking volume and stable agent identity resolving display order. Equal listing counts share a competition rank, including across pages. Observed listing share is credited homes divided by unique eligible homes in the edition; co-listing credits can overlap.

Asking Volume adds the latest usable observed asking price associated with each selected episode. A volume rank requires 100% usable price coverage. These are asking prices rather than recorded sale proceeds. Homes with missing prices still count toward Homes Listed. Typical Asking Price describes the stored median and priced-home sample; historical price-based standings retain their original five-home and 90% coverage eligibility policy.

Each geography freezes the first successful verified capture for its UTC monthly edition. Read the actual reporting window, cutoff and publication date on the page. Daily ingestion prepares evidence separately. Published historical figures are preserved; a correction creates a new revision.

Each comparison covers the geography, reporting window and qualifying records stated in the edition. Supporting listings show the evidence behind the figures. Payment never changes eligibility, counts or rank.

## Cite this leaderboard

Cribber. Top Real Estate Agents in Sanibel, FL | Cribber. 2026-10 edition, Homes Listed. Reporting window: 2025-10-26–2026-10-26. Published 2026-10-26T17:08:54.734843+00:00. https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents?month=2026-10&sort=homes_listed

Canonical leaderboard: https://cribber.ai/leaderboard/sanibel/top-agents