Story Hill, Milwaukee housing market, October 2026: the estimated median asking price was $274,900 (up 5.7% vs October 2025). 308 homes were listed for sale during the month (-25.8% vs October 2025) with an average of 39.2 days on market. The market leans toward sellers, based on asking prices, inventory and time on market for active listings.
So far in November 2026 (through November 16, 2026): $269,900 estimated median asking price, 302 listings.
Updated · Data for · Source: monthly ZIP listing statistics · How we measure
October 2026 prices, inventory and trends
Market data for Story Hill, Milwaukee shares its ZIP coverage or recorded market figures with Johnson's Woods. See the Johnson's Woods report.
As of · Month to date
Estimated median asking price
$269,900
Active listings during month
302
Average days on market
43.5 days
Average asking price / sq ft
$173
Buying here?
Use inventory and time on market to understand your options. Compare a listing with nearby peers before your next conversation.
See the asking prices and competition around you. Explore agents’ local listing activity as you plan your next move.
Story Hill, Milwaukee, WI home prices over time
The estimated median asking price for the ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $274,900 in October 2026, up 5.7% vs October 2025.
October 2025–November 2026 · November 2026 is month to date
Estimated median asking price
$269,900
Nov 2026 · Month to date
The estimated median asking price for the ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $269,900 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
View data
Estimated median asking price
Date
Value
2025-10
$259,995
2025-11
$260,000
2025-12
$259,900
2026-01
$259,900
2026-02
$259,900
2026-03
$269,999
2026-04
$274,900
2026-05
$260,000
2026-06
$275,000
2026-07
$279,900
2026-08
$275,000
2026-09
$275,000
2026-10
$274,900
2026-11
$269,900
Active listings during month
302
Nov 2026 · Month to date
There were 302 active listings in the ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee during November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
View data
Active listings during month
Date
Value
2025-10
415
2025-11
370
2025-12
303
2026-01
253
2026-02
258
2026-03
259
2026-04
277
2026-05
313
2026-06
338
2026-07
299
2026-08
307
2026-09
317
2026-10
308
2026-11
302
How long do homes stay on the market in Story Hill, Milwaukee, WI?
The average time on market for the ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was 43.5 days in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
October 2025–November 2026 · November 2026 is month to date
Average days on market
43.5 days
Nov 2026 · Month to date
The average time on market for the ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was 43.5 days in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
View data
Average days on market
Date
Value
2025-10
48.8 days
2025-11
55.3 days
2025-12
64.3 days
2026-01
68.7 days
2026-02
58.1 days
2026-03
41 days
2026-04
38.5 days
2026-05
38.1 days
2026-06
36.7 days
2026-07
29.8 days
2026-08
33.5 days
2026-09
35.2 days
2026-10
39.2 days
2026-11
43.5 days
Average asking price / sq ft
$173 / sq ft
Nov 2026 · Month to date
The average asking price per square foot for the ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $173 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
View data
Average asking price / sq ft
Date
Value
2025-10
$171 / sq ft
2025-11
$171 / sq ft
2025-12
$167 / sq ft
2026-01
$165 / sq ft
2026-02
$170 / sq ft
2026-03
$175 / sq ft
2026-04
$179 / sq ft
2026-05
$184 / sq ft
2026-06
$185 / sq ft
2026-07
$181 / sq ft
2026-08
$180 / sq ft
2026-09
$183 / sq ft
2026-10
$175 / sq ft
2026-11
$173 / sq ft
Story Hill, Milwaukee, WI home prices & inventory by bedroom count
October 2025–November 2026 · November 2026 is month to date
Choose one or more bedroom counts to compare.
Average asking price
Nov 2026 · Month to date
2 bed$223,8503 of 3 ZIPs
The average asking price for 2-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $223,850 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
Takeaways for other bedroom counts
The average asking price for 3-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $320,878 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
The average asking price for 4-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $305,907 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
The average asking price for 5-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $330,911 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
The average asking price for 6-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $349,561 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
Hover or tap the chart to compare a month.
Changes, coverage & data
2-bedroom homes
$223,850
3 of 3 ZIPs
Comparison values
Date
2-bedroom homes
Oct 2025
$226,769
Nov 2025
$234,143
Dec 2025
$208,129
Jan 2026
$193,294
Feb 2026
$218,387
Mar 2026
$205,783
Apr 2026
$208,728
May 2026
$224,465
Jun 2026
$234,377
Jul 2026
$232,020
Aug 2026
$246,661
Sep 2026
$235,300
Oct 2026
$228,637
Nov 2026
$223,850
Reported active listings during month
Nov 2026 · Month to date
2 bed263 of 3 ZIPs
There were 26 active listings for 2-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee during November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
Takeaways for other bedroom counts
There were 100 active listings for 3-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee during November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
There were 92 active listings for 4-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee during November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
There were 26 active listings for 5-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee during November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
There were 24 active listings for 6-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee during November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
Hover or tap the chart to compare a month.
Changes, coverage & data
2-bedroom homes
26
3 of 3 ZIPs
Comparison values
Date
2-bedroom homes
Oct 2025
39
Nov 2025
28
Dec 2025
17
Jan 2026
18
Feb 2026
19
Mar 2026
21
Apr 2026
18
May 2026
26
Jun 2026
27
Jul 2026
23
Aug 2026
27
Sep 2026
25
Oct 2026
27
Nov 2026
26
Average days on market
Nov 2026 · Month to date
2 bed25.5 days3 of 3 ZIPs
The average time on market for 2-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was 25.5 days in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
Takeaways for other bedroom counts
The average time on market for 3-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was 33.3 days in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
The average time on market for 4-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was 46.4 days in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
The average time on market for 5-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was 44.3 days in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
The average time on market for 6-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was 67.4 days in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
Hover or tap the chart to compare a month.
Changes, coverage & data
2-bedroom homes
25.5 days
3 of 3 ZIPs
Comparison values
Date
2-bedroom homes
Oct 2025
48.8 days
Nov 2025
53.3 days
Dec 2025
65.6 days
Jan 2026
39.5 days
Feb 2026
18.4 days
Mar 2026
15 days
Apr 2026
19.6 days
May 2026
17 days
Jun 2026
14.6 days
Jul 2026
17.1 days
Aug 2026
17.9 days
Sep 2026
16.7 days
Oct 2026
20.1 days
Nov 2026
25.5 days
Average asking price / sq ft
Nov 2026 · Month to date
2 bed$228 / sq ft3 of 3 ZIPs
The average asking price per square foot for 2-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $228 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
Takeaways for other bedroom counts
The average asking price per square foot for 3-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $205 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
The average asking price per square foot for 4-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $162 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
The average asking price per square foot for 5-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $147 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
The average asking price per square foot for 6-bedroom homes in the reporting ZIPs associated with Story Hill, Milwaukee was $115 in November 2026 to date (through Nov 16).
Hover or tap the chart to compare a month.
Changes, coverage & data
2-bedroom homes
$228 / sq ft
3 of 3 ZIPs
Comparison values
Date
2-bedroom homes
Oct 2025
$204 / sq ft
Nov 2025
$207 / sq ft
Dec 2025
$198 / sq ft
Jan 2026
$189 / sq ft
Feb 2026
$217 / sq ft
Mar 2026
$188 / sq ft
Apr 2026
$203 / sq ft
May 2026
$228 / sq ft
Jun 2026
$241 / sq ft
Jul 2026
$240 / sq ft
Aug 2026
$231 / sq ft
Sep 2026
$232 / sq ft
Oct 2026
$230 / sq ft
Nov 2026
$228 / sq ft
Top agents
Story Hill · published edition · cutoff Nov 17, 2026
Homes listed are active listings during the latest available month. Asking price is the ZIP median when a neighborhood is one ZIP, and an estimated median weighted by listing count when it covers more than one.
Prices are asking (list) prices, not completed sale prices. Monthly inventory counts listings active at any point in the month. Days on market measures the age of active listings. Asking price per square foot uses the reported ZIP statistic, weighted by listing count where multiple ZIPs are combined. Estimated median asking prices weight each ZIP’s reported median by its listing count. Associated ZIPs can extend beyond the named area.
Market lean requires at least three listing signals. Over 12 months, inventory and days on market use a 10% threshold and asking prices use 2%. For shorter windows the price and days thresholds are scaled by the number of months divided by 12. The shorter window uses the level of days on market in place of the inventory change, with 60 days or more favoring buyers and 30 days or less favoring sellers. A share of 50% or more listed for 60 or more days favors buyers, and a share of 30% or less favors sellers. A score of +2 or higher leans toward buyers, −2 or lower leans toward sellers, and the rest are balanced.